April 22, 2013

ENT Sued for Wrongful Death from Airway Closure

Media reported on a malpractice case whereby in October 2010, a woman presented to the emergency room at Ochsner Medical Center (Louisiana) with symptoms of sore throat, neck pain, and painful swallowing.

A CT neck performed at that time revealed "swelling in her neck and a narrowing at the top of the throat" [link]. Patient was given a strong pain medication to help with her discomfort (presumably a narcotic), admitted into the hospital, and ENT consulted for further evaluation and management. Unfortunately, the patient's airway completely closed early the next morning resulting in a massive brain injury due to oxygen deprivation with eventual withdrawal of life support four days later.

Lawsuit against the hospital and ENT among others pending.

What could have happened?

Based on the limited information provided, it seems that the airway swelling noted on the CT scan could have been due to a large peritonsillar abscess, throat tumor, or epiglottitis.

A peritonsillar abscess is basically a tonsillitis gone real bad with pus collecting under the tonsil causing it to swell. This condition could have been treated quickly with an incision and drainage.

Epiglottitis is when the "throat flap" becomes infected resulting in massive swelling which can lead to airway closure. Typical management would include IV antibiotics, IV steroids, and close observation. If airway truly becomes critical, an awake tracheostomy should be pursued. However, medical management is most always tried first if airway is still patent (albeit narrowed).

Throat tumor (ie, cancer) is pretty much a large growth in the throat causing airway narrowing. Treatment is an emergent awake tracheostomy followed by biopsies to determine what type of cancer is present so that treatment can be pursued as quickly as possible.

It is unclear from media reports exactly what was causing the airway narrowing and whether ENT had even seen the patient until the airway closed off. Also unclear was whether the ENT was made aware just how critical the airway was.

A tragedy...

Source:
Daughter of woman who died from brain damage after airway swollen shut sues hospital. The Louisiana Record 4/15/13
Fauquier blog
Fauquier ENT

Dr. Christopher Chang is a private practice otolaryngology, head & neck surgeon specializing in the treatment of problems related to the ear, nose, and throat. Located in Warrenton, VA about 45 minutes west of Washington DC, he also provides inhalant allergy testing/treatment, hearing tests, and dispenses hearing aids.

You might be interested in reading...

  • Singer Ed Sheeran Suffers Traumatic Eardrum Rupture
    12/11/2015 - 0 Comments
    Image from Wikipedia by Eva Rinaldi Singer Ed Sheeran revealed that he traumatically ruptured his…
  • Music in the Operating Room - Good or Bad?
    08/09/2015 - 0 Comments
    Image courtesy of Stuart Miles at FreeDigitalPhotos.net Does music in the operating room help or hurt…
  • Tongue Tie Classification and Impact on Breastfeeding
    04/26/2018 - 0 Comments
    Parents with tongue-tied infants often wonder how tongue tie classification influences decision to perform…
  • Narcotics Family Tree
    11/10/2015 - 0 Comments
    Sometimes it is instructive to see how all the different narcotics are related to each other. It may…
  • Sudden Hearing Loss Can Be Due to Erectile Dysfunction Medications (Cialis, Viagra, etc)
    04/26/2010 - 1 Comments
    It's been a few years since the warning has come out from the FDA regarding sudden hearing loss in men who…
  • Device for Meniere's Disease and Eustachian Tube Dysfunction
    12/20/2006 - 0 Comments
    This blog is an OPINION and not medical advice. See your doctor with any questions.Enttex is an Australian…
  • The Rationing of High Cost Healthcare
    06/10/2012 - 0 Comments
    I would like to start this blog article with an extreme hypothetical situation... Imagine a pharmaceutical…
  • Chewing Gum Improves Memory?!!
    08/25/2009 - 0 Comments
    Image by Mayr from Wikipedia I came across interesting research that hinted at the possibility that…

Banner Map

Pediatric Neck Masses

Adult Neck Mass Workup